• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

S O R E

  • About
  • Updates
  • Hotel Proposal
  • Subdivision Proposal
  • Benny Marotta Media Archive
  • How You Can Help
You are here: Home / Updates / Update on Marotta subdivision proposal – Heritage Act permits

Update on Marotta subdivision proposal – Heritage Act permits

Article posted on April 14, 2023

On April 12, the Town’s Municipal Heritage Committee met to discuss several permit applications by the Marotta group under the Heritage Act to demolish/alter designated heritage attributes at the Rand Estate.  Without the permits, the subdivision as proposed cannot proceed.

The MHC had in front of it an 850-page report by Town heritage planner Denise Horne, which recommended that most of the permit applications be DENIED.

MHC heard delegations from the Marotta group and from SORE.  A member of the public also delegated.

After hearing the delegations, MHC unanimously recommended to Council that Ms. Horne’s recommendations be approved.   A friendly amendment to that motion also carried unanimously that the Carriage House should not be permitted to be demolished.  This is consistent with Ms. Horne’s recommendation.

Council has now set a special in-person meeting on April 24 at 5 pm at the Community Centre to make a decision on the Marotta Heritage Act permit applications.  (Council must make that decision within 90 days of the permit applications being deemed complete.)

Mr. Marotta long ago took away from Council the decision-making authority on his Rand subdivision proposal by appealing his Planning Act applications directly to the OLT.  That Tribunal will have the benefit of extensive expert evidence, tested by cross examination, prior to making a decision.  It is possible that the OLT will deny the application in its entirely.  There are myriad reasons why the Tribunal could come to that conclusion.  Surely the only logical approach for Council on April 24 is to deny in their entirety the Heritage Act permits requested by the Marotta group.  That decision will then be appealed by those companies to the OLT and joined with the Planning Act applications already there.  The OLT has scheduled a case management conference on June 9 to settle the issues list for the hearing.  All of the Heritage Act issues should, SORE strongly submits, be on that list.  Any other approach would be illogical.  

It is noteworthy that the SORE residential development concept for the back half of the Rand Estate conserves virtually all heritage attributes Mr. Marotta wants to demolish.  SORE will be reminding Council of that on April 24.  We look forward to seeing you there! 

View all updates from SORE

View 2021 subdivision application documents

Footer

Latest posts by SORE

  • Marotta continues Rand litigation against Town and promises new lawsuit against Council
  • Residents Association press release
  • Ontario Land Tribunal dismisses Marotta Rand subdivision application
  • The Niagara Foundation moves forward on The Wilderness
  • Ontario Land Tribunal denies Marotta appeal of Rand subdivision decision
  • Marotta appeals Ontario Land Tribunal Rand decision
  • Town and SORE win OLT Rand case on Marotta subdivision

On SORE website

  • Updates
  • 2022 municipal election
  • How You Can Help
  • Benny Marotta the Developer- Media Archive
  • History of Randwood Estate
  • 2021 Rand Subdivision proposal documents
  • 2018 Hotel Proposal Documents
  • 2018 Hotel Proposal Media Coverage
  • 2018 Hotel Proposal Process
  • December 2019 SORE Update

Contact SORE

Email us with questions, interest and support at  [email protected]

Sign up for SORE updates

Sign up to receive email updates from SORE. *Name and email required
This field is required.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your email signup to SORE.

The Save Our Rand Estate (SORE) website has been developed by SORE Association, a group of concerned local citizens in Niagara on the Lake, with information we believe to be accurate.

Please contact SORE Association with any questions or concerns. | We respect your privacy

Website hosting by Inspiring Media Inc.